The Pitcher Inn has a total of eleven rooms and suites, of which nine are unique double-occupancy rooms located in the main house and two are two bedroom suites, situated in the barn which is adjacent to the main house. Excluding extra beds, we can accommodate 13 couples or 26 people at the Inn. For exclusive use and house party events, with extra beds and pull out sofa beds, this number can be increased to 33 guests. Each room was designed and decorated to be distinctly different but with a common Vermont theme. Appointed with original art, memorabilia and antiques, the guest rooms provide a comfortable and subtly luxurious atmosphere. All rooms feature individual air-climate controls, three line telephones with DSL data port and Wi-Fi access, CD music player and concealed television with VHS player. In addition, all private baths have Jacuzzi tubs and radiant floor heating. Some rooms also offer steam showers and the majority have wood burning fireplaces and king beds.

The two suites are known as "Stable" and "Hayloft". These are located in a barn next to the main house and are ideal for the traveling family or two couples. Stable is a two-bedroom suite, located on the lower level of the barn. The master bedroom has a king size bed, while the second bedroom has two twin beds with each bedroom having private ensuite bathrooms. There is a living room with a comfortable seating area and a view of the garden. True to its name, Stable is decorated with bridles, saddles and equipment that usually can be found in a stable. Decorated with antique barn supplies, Hayloft is located up-stairs, on the second level of the barn and features two identically sized king bedrooms with a common living room separating them.